PTLR Core Papers

• This page is referenced in the Patent Thicket Literature Review

This page details the 'Core' papers of the Patent Thicket Literature Review (PTLR). A paper is 'core' if it explicitly models or studies patent thickets.

Pages containing previous versions of papers are indented below their subsequent version. Write-ups will only be done for the subsequent versions. The BibTex entries for these papers are available as a list on the PTLR Core Group Processed BibTeX page, and each paper page has its own BibTeX entry in its reference section.

The Paper Pages

1. Clarkson (2004) - Objective Identification Of Patent Thickets A Network Analytic Approach
2. Clarkson (2005) - Patent Informatics For Patent Thicket Detection
3. Clarkson DeKorte (2006) - The Problem Of Patent Thickets In Convergent Technologies
4. Cockburn MacGarvie (2009) - Patents Thickets And The Financing Of Early Stage Firms
5. Cockburn MacGarvie Muller (2010) - Patent Thickets Licensing And Innovative Performance
6. Cockburn Macgarvie (2011) - Entry And Patenting In The Software Industry
   • Cockburn MacGarvie (2006) - Entry And Patenting In The Software Industry
7. Entezarkheir (2010) - Patent Thickets And Market Value An Empirical Analysis
8. Epstein Kuhlik (2004) - Is There A Biomedical Anticommons
9. Evans LayneFarrar (2004) - Software Patents And Open Source
10. Farrell (2009) - Intellectual Property As A Bargaining Environment
11. Galasso Schankerman (2010) - Patent Thickets Courts And The Market For Innovation
    • Galasso Schankerman (2008) - Patent Thickets And The Market For Innovation
12. George (2006) - What Is Hiding In The Bushes Ebays Effect On Holdout Behavior In Patent Thickets
13. Geradin (2007) - Royalty Stacking In High Tech Industries Separating Myth From Reality
14. Geradin LayneFarrar PadillaBlanco (2008) - The Complements Problem Within Standard Setting
15. Hall (2012) - A Study Of Patent Thickets
16. Hall Ziedonis (2001) - The Patent Paradox Revisited
17. Hargreaves (2011) - Digital Opportunity
18. Harhoff VonGraevenitz Wagner (2012) - Conflict Resolution Public Goods And Patent Thickets
19. Hegde Mowery Graham (2009) - Pioneering Inventors Or Thicket Builders
20. Heller Eisenberg (1998) - Can Patents Deter Innovation The Anticommons In Biomedical Research
21. Huang Murray (2009) - Does Patent Strategy Shape The Long Run Supply Of Public Knowledge
22. Mann (2004) - The Myth Of The Software Patent Thicket
23. Merges (1999) - Institutions For Intellectual Property Transactions
24. Merges Nelson (1990) - On The Complex Economics Of Patent Scope
25. Mossoff (2009) - A Stitch In Time The Rise And Fall Of The Sewing Machine Patent Thicket
26. Mossoff (2011) - Rise And Fall Of The First American Patent Thicket
27. Murray Stern (2007) - Do Formal Intellectual Property Rights Hinder The Free Flow Of Scientific Knowledge
28. Nagaoka Nishimura (2006) - An Empirical Assessment Of The Effects Of Patent Thickets
29. Noel Schankerman (2006) - Strategic Patenting And Software Innovation
30. Regibeau Rockett (2011) - Assessment Of Potential Anticompetitive Conduct
31. Reitzig (2004) - The Private Values Of Thickets And Fences
32. Schacht (2006) - Patent Reform Issues In The Biomedical And Software Industries
33. Shapiro (2001) - Navigating The Patent Thicket
34. Siebert VonGraevenitz (2010) - Jostling For Advantage Or Not
35. Siebert VonGraevenitz (2010) - Licensing In The Patent Thicket Timing And Benefits
    • Siebert VonGraevenitz (2008) - Does Licensing Resolve Hold Up In The Patent Thicket
36. Sternitzke Bartkowski Schramm (2008) - Visualizing Patent Statistics By Means Of Social Network Analysis Tools
37. Strandburg (2006) - Law And The Science Of Networks
38. UKIPO (2011) - Patent Thickets An Overview
39. VonGraevenitz Wagner Harhoff (2011) - How To Measure Patent Thickets A Novel Approach
40. VonGraevenitz (2012) - Incidence And Growth Of Patent Thickets
    • Harhoff (2008) - Incidence And Growth Of Patent Thickets
41. Walsh Arora Cohen (2003) - Effects Of Research Tool Patents And Licensing On Biomedical Innovation
42. Ziedonis (2004) - Dont Fence Me In

Sorted By Area

Empirical Papers

1. Cockburn MacGarvie (2009) - Patents Thickets And The Financing Of Early Stage Firms
2. Cockburn MacGarvie Muller (2010) - Patent Thickets Licensing And Innovative Performance
3. Cockburn Macgarvie (2011) - Entry And Patenting In The Software Industry
   • Cockburn MacGarvie (2006) - Entry And Patenting In The Software Industry
4. Entezarkheir (2010) - Patent Thickets And Market Value An Empirical Analysis
5. Hall (2012) - A Study Of Patent Thickets
6. Hall Ziedonis (2001) - The Patent Paradox Revisited
7. Hegde Mowery Graham (2009) - Pioneering Inventors Or Thicket Builders
8. Huang Murray (2009) - Does Patent Strategy Shape The Long Run Supply Of Public Knowledge
9. Murray Stern (2007) - Do Formal Intellectual Property Rights Hinder The Free Flow Of Scientific Knowledge
10. Nagaoka Nishimura (2006) - An Empirical Assessment Of The Effects Of Patent Thickets
11. Reitzig (2004) - The Private Values Of Thickets And Fences
12. Ziedonis (2004) - Dont Fence Me In

Theory Papers

Informal Theory

1. Farrell (2009) - Intellectual Property As A Bargaining Environment
2. Shapiro (2001) - Navigating The Patent Thicket
3. Walsh Arora Cohen (2003) - Effects Of Research Tool Patents And Licensing On Biomedical Innovation

Formal Theory With Empirics

1. Galasso Schankerman (2010) - Patent Thickets Courts And The Market For Innovation
2. Geradin (2007) - Royalty Stacking In High Tech Industries Separating Myth From Reality
3. Harhoff VonGraevenitz Wagner (2012) - Conflict Resolution Public Goods And Patent Thickets
4. Noel Schankerman (2006) - Strategic Patenting And Software Innovation
5. Siebert VonGraevenitz (2010) - Jostling For Advantage Or Not
6. Siebert VonGraevenitz (2010) - Licensing In The Patent Thicket Timing And Benefits
   • Siebert VonGraevenitz (2008) - Does Licensing Resolve Hold Up In The Patent Thicket
7. VonGraevenitz (2012) - Incidence And Growth Of Patent Thickets
   • Harhoff (2008) - Incidence And Growth Of Patent Thickets

Measures Papers

1. Clarkson (2004) - Objective Identification Of Patent Thickets A Network Analytic Approach
2. Clarkson (2005) - Patent Informatics For Patent Thicket Detection
3. Clarkson DeKorte (2006) - The Problem Of Patent Thickets In Convergent Technologies
4. Sternitzke Bartkowski Schramm (2008) - Visualizing Patent Statistics By Means Of Social Network Analysis Tools
5. Strandburg (2006) - Law And The Science Of Networks
6. VonGraevenitz Wagner Harhoff (2011) - How To Measure Patent Thickets A Novel Approach

Law Papers

1. Epstein Kuhlik (2004) - Is There A Biomedical Anticommons
2. Evans LayneFarrar (2004) - Software Patents And Open Source
3. Geradin LayneFarrar PadillaBlanco (2008) - The Complements Problem Within Standard Setting
4. Heller Eisenberg (1998) - Can Patents Deter Innovation The Anticommons In Biomedical Research
5. Merges (1999) - Institutions For Intellectual Property Transactions
6. Merges Nelson (1990) - On The Complex Economics Of Patent Scope
7. Mossoff (2009) - A Stitch In Time The Rise And Fall Of The Sewing Machine Patent Thicket
8. Mossoff (2011) - Rise And Fall Of The First American Patent Thicket

Survey/Empirical Law

1. Mann (2004) - The Myth Of The Software Patent Thicket

Policy Report

1. Hargreaves (2011) - Digital Opportunity
2. Regibeau Rockett (2011) - Assessment Of Potential Anticompetitive Conduct
3. Schacht (2006) - Patent Reform Issues In The Biomedical And Software Industries
4. UKIPO (2011) - Patent Thickets An Overview

Non-Core Papers

The following papers do not explicitly discuss patent thickets but are vital to an understanding of thickets or their measures:

1. Hall (2005) - A Note On The Bias In Herfindahl Type Measures Based On Count Data

The following papers were erroneously classified as core:

1. Cockburn Wagner (2007) - Patents And The Survival Of Internet Related Ipos

Paper Origins

The vast major of these papers were contained in the first download. However, the following four papers were found during the convergence process:

1. Merges (1999) - Institutions For Intellectual Property Transactions
2. Merges Nelson (1990) - On The Complex Economics Of Patent Scope
3. Murray Stern (2007) - Do Formal Intellectual Property Rights Hinder The Free Flow Of Scientific Knowledge
4. Walsh Arora Cohen (2003) - Effects Of Research Tool Patents And Licensing On Biomedical Innovation

And the following paper was added as it was referenced in the review done by Kirti Gupta, deemed to be directly about thickets, and we didn't have it:

1. Epstein Kuhlik (2004) - Is There A Biomedical Anticommons