Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
#Test the effects of using a framework on various outcomes.
In my letter to the reviewer, I can explain that this paper is for a special issue and that the editors and I have agreed that this should not be and an empirical paper and that should not contain regressions or other tests. That might tamp down their vitriol somewhat.Whether I deliver back a "major revision" is in the eye of the beholder, and there's no need to draw attention to this demand. ====RP Constraints==== Although no-one has asked me to, I need to cut down the length of the paper. RP asks for a maximum word count of 8,000-10,000, though does allow exceptions. Using pdftotext and wc, or doing a count in the tex file, it looks like I'm up near 17k. However, both approaches drastically inflate the total with table entries, TeX commands, etc. I expect the current true count is closer to 14k. A different way of coming at the problem is to say that I'm using 12pt font with 1" margins and one-half line spacing (as implemented using \onehalfspacing in LaTeX, which [https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/65849/confusion-onehalfspacing-vs-spacing-vs-word-vs-the-world isn't the same as 1.5 spacing in word]). AER restricts to 40 pages using this format[https://eml.berkeley.edu//~sdellavi/wp/pagelimits12-12-11.pdf], and Management Science restricts to 32 pages[https://pubsonline.informs.org/page/mnsc/submission-guidelines]. With averages of perhaps 15 words per line and 32 lines per page, this would give just shy of 500 words per page, making 10k words, 20 pages of dense text, and perhaps 30 pages with figures, tables, quotes, headings, definitions, etc.  Because the last round was also an R&R, I presumably met all the other constraints.  
====Reviewer 1's Comments====

Navigation menu