Demsetz (1968) - Why Regulate Utilities

Article
Has bibtex key
Has article title
Has year	1968
In journal
In volume
In number
Has pages
Has publisher
© edegan.com, 2016

Reference(s)

Demsetz, Harold (1968), "Why Regulate Utilities", Journal of Law and Economics, 11, April, pp. 55-56. pdf

Abstract

Current economic doctrine offers to its students a basic relationship be- tween the number of firms that produce for a given market and the degree to which competitive results will prevail. Stated explicitly or suggested im- plicitly is the doctrine that price and output can be expected to diverge to a greater extent from their competitive levels the fewer the firms that produce the product for the market. This relationship has provided the logic that motivates much of the research devoted to studying industrial concen- tration, and it has given considerable support to utility regulation.x In this paper, I shall argue that the asserted relationship between market concentration and competition cannot be derived from existing theoretical considerations and that it is based largely on an incorrect understanding of the concept of competition or rivalry. The strongest application of the asserted relationship is in the area of utility regulation since, if we assume scale economies in prbduction, it can be deduced that only one firm will produce the commodity. The logical validity or falsity of the asserted rela- tionship should reveal itself most clearly in this case. Although public utility regulation recently has been criticized because of its ineffectiveness or because of the undesirable indirect effects it produces,2 the basic intellectual arguments for believing that truly effective regulation is desirable have not been challenged. Even those who are inclined to reject government regulation or ownership of public utilities because they believe these alternatives are more undesirable than private monopoly, implicitly accept the intellectual arguments that underlie regulation.