Incubator Seed Data

Project

Incubator Seed Data
Project Information
Has title	Incubator Seed Data
Has owner	Anne Freeman
Has start date
Has deadline date
Has project status	Active
Is dependent on	Crunchbase Database
Subsumed by:	Ecosystem Organization Classifier
Copyright © 2019 edegan.com. All Rights Reserved.

Goal

We will evaluate data sources based on the number of incubators they have data on and the type of information they supply on these incubators. We will also record whether or not these data sources collect information on any other types of entrepreneurship organizations. Ideally these data sources would provide some or all of the variables that were identified as most important for identifying incubators (Formulate_baseline_attributes). However, it is unlikely that one data source will contain all of the baseline attributes identified, therefore if the data source can provide links to a large quantity of incubators or in-depth descriptions, they could still be viable.

Evaluation of Sources from Specific Google Searches

• Searches included:

• "incubator database"
• "us business incubators database"

Source: https://www.whartoneclub.com/resources/entrepreneurship/incubators/

1. Opened source link
2. Copied results from "U.S. Based Incubators" into excel spreadsheet
3. Returned list of 21 US Based Incubators
4. Data

• Name
• Url to home Page
• City, State (In parentheses next to name)

Review

• Provides links to the home page url of incubator, may not be able to get very specific information about the incubator with a web crawler
• Some of the incubators may not fall under our definition of an incubator (e.g. Y Combinator)

Source: http://exchange.inbia.org/network/findacompany/

1. Opened source link
2. Entered "United States" for country information and clicked "Find Companies"
3. Received 415 results for economic development organizations within the US
4. Data

• Company Name and address
• Link to another page within inbia

• That page contains a link to the company's homepage

Review

• This may be a good source to find incubators as this database contains a lot of information on economic development institutions
• Limitation: It would be challenging to collect this data via web crawler as the link on the database connects to another page within inbia and then the link on that page connects to the company's homepage, which sometimes does not have enough information.
• Limitation: Not all of the institutions listed are incubators. Out of the first 10 links there were:

• 4 incubators
• 2 educational programs
• 1 broken link
• 3 other economic development programs

Source: https://www.clustermapping.us/organization-type/innovation-and-entrepreneurship-support-organizations

1. Opened source link
2. Received 292 results for Innovation and Entrepreneurship Support Organizations in the US
3. Data

1. Brief Description
2. Company name with link to a separate page within cluster mapping

1. Link to Company Website
2. Regions

Review

• Provides a long list of entrepreneurship organizations
• Limitation: Often data is missing off of the separate page for the company, including the URL to the company's website. The description is often not detailed enough to determine the category for the economic organization without going to the company's website.
• Limitation: Different types of entrepreneurship organizations are mixed together
• Using the first 10 links, three were accelerators, six were missing links (two were self-proclaimed incubators in description), and one was another type of support organization.

Evaluation of Sources from INIBIA List of US Accelerator Associations

The National Business Incubation Association maintains a list of U.S. Incubation Associations. We went through this list and evaluated each association as a potential data source. These sites generally contain a list of incubators that are working in collaboration with the NBIA and are within that specific state. The sites could be useful in cross-referencing data pulled from the NBIA main database as some of the incubators listed on the state specific websites are not in the main NBIA database.

Source: Alabama Business Incubation Network

1. Opened source link
2. Counted incubators listed on the home page and found information for 12 incubators
3. Data

• Incubator Name, Brief Description, and a link to the home page

Review

• Provides reliable links to incubators within Alabama
• Benefit: data is filtered to include only incubators
• Limitation: only incubators within Alabama

Source: http://www.fbiaonline.org/Incubators/incubators.htm Florida Business Incubation Association (FBIA)

1. Opened source link
2. Opened links for each of the four regions in Florida
3. Counted incubators listed in each of the four regions to get information on 66 incubators
4. Data

• main site contains links to four regions in Florida, each region contains the following data:

• incubator name, address, phone number and link to home page

Review

• Provides reliable links to incubators within Florida
• Benefit: data is filtered to include only incubators
• Limitation: may be challenging for a web crawler to navigate, as main page has links to regions which has links to home pages of incubators
• Limitation: only incubators within Florida

Source: https://www.louisianaincubation.org/current-members Louisiana Business Incubation Association

1. Opened source link
2. Copied the data on incubators into a text editor and searched for how many times the word "E-Mail" appeared
3. Site contained data on 28 incubators in the state of Louisiana
4. Data

• Main site contains
• incubator name
• contact name
• address and phone number
• link to website

Review

• Provides reliable links to incubators within Louisiana
• Benefit: data is filtered to include only incubators
• Limitation: may be challenging for a web crawler to navigate, as main page does not contain information on incubator but rather has links to home pages of incubators
• Limitation: only incubators within Louisiana

Source: http://incubatemaryland.org/incubators/ Maryland Business Incubation Association

1. Opened source link
2. Counted number of incubators listed on the page and found information on 35 incubators
3. Data

• Main site contains incubator name, short description and link to another page within main site read more which contains:

• link to incubate home page

Review

• Provides reliable links to incubators within Maryland
• Benefit: data is filtered to include only incubators
• Limitation: may be challenging for a web crawler to navigate, as main page contains links internal to the site which then link to the home pages of incubators
• Limitation: only incubators within Maryland

Source: https://www.massincubators.org/ Massachusetts Association of Business Incubators

1. Opened source link
2. Counted number of incubators listed on the page and found information on 20 incubators
3. Data

• Main site contains incubator name, short description and link to the incubator's home page

Review

• Provides reliable links to incubators within Massachusetts
• Benefit: data is filtered to include only incubators
• Limitation: only incubators within Massachusetts

Accelerator Data Sources that are Potentially Viable

Source: http://www.acceleratorinfo.com/see-all.html

1. Opened source link
2. Copied links from first column (“All Startup Support Programs”) into excel and returned 215 results
3. Copied links from second column (“All University Programs”) into excel and returned 249 results)
4. Each link on parent list leads to individual home page url of organization

Review

• Provides only links, does not separate between incubator and accelerator, some of the university supported programs may not be considered either an incubator or an accelerator

Source: https://bostonstartupsguide.com/guide/every-boston-startup-accelerator-incubator/

1. Scrolled down to the section labeled "Startup incubators in Boston"
2. Counted the number of incubators in Boston (10)
3. Data

1. Company Name and URL
2. Capital Provide
3. Equity taken
4. Application Process

Review

• The data is relatively unformatted and would be a challenge to use
• It is limited in scope to the Boston Area and only provides information on 10 incubators

Accelerator Data Sources that are not viable

• Source: http://www.seed-db.com/accelerators

• Reason: does not include information on incubators
• Learn More: Previous Research

• Source: https://www.f6s.com/programs?type

• Reason: data is cluttered/messy, does not provide links to incubator websites and doesn't include enough information for evaluation without incubator url
• Learn More: Previous Research

• Source: http://gust.com/usa-canada-accelerator-report-2015/

• Reason: does not include information on incubators
• Learn More: Previous Research

• Source: https://www.corporate-accelerators.net/database/

• Reason: this website is no longer active, the link will not work
• Learn More: Previous Research

• Source: https://github.com/florianheinemann/www-corporate-accelerators-net/blob/master/_data/Accelerators.json

• Reason: does not include information on incubators
• Learn More: Previous Research